TY - JOUR
T1 - Supersonic turbulent boundary layer drag control using spanwise wall oscillation
AU - Yao, Jie
AU - Hussain, Fazle
N1 - Publisher Copyright:
© 2019 Cambridge University Press.
PY - 2019/12/10
Y1 - 2019/12/10
N2 - Spanwise wall oscillation has been extensively studied to explore possible drag control methods, mechanisms and efficacy - particularly for incompressible flows. We performed direct numerical simulation for fully developed turbulent channel flow to establish how effective spanwise wall oscillation is when the flow is compressible and also to document its drag reduction (DR) trend with Mach number. Drag reduction DR is first investigated for three different bulk Mach numbers Mb D0:3, 0:8 and 1:5 at a fixed bulk Reynolds number Reb D3000. At a given velocity amplitude AC (D12), DR at MbD0:3 agrees with the strictly incompressible case; at MbD0:8, DR exhibits a similar trend to that at Mb D 0:3: DR increases with the oscillation period TC to a maximum and then decreases gradually. However, at Mb D 1:5, DR monotonically increases with TC. In addition, the maximum DR is found to increase with Mb. For Mb D 1:5, similar to the incompressible case, DR increases with AC, but the rate of increase decreases at larger AC. Unlike the flow behaviour when incompressible, the flow surprisingly relaminarizes when it is supersonic (at AC D 18 and TC D 300) - this enigmatic behaviour requires further detailed studies for different domain sizes, Reb and Mb. The Reynolds number effect on DR is also investigated. Although DR generally decreases with Reb, it is less affected at small TC, but drops rapidly at large TC. We introduce a simple scaling for the oscillation period as T∗ DTC C lC I =lC C , with lC I and lC C denoting the mean streak spacing for incompressible and compressible cases, respectively. At the same semi-local Reynolds number Re∗τ c = Reτ √pc=√w=.μc=μw/(subscripts c and w denote quantities at the channel centre and wall, respectively), DR as a function of T∗ exhibits good agreement between the supersonic and strictly incompressible cases, with the optimal oscillation period becoming Mb-invariant as T∗ opt ≈100.
AB - Spanwise wall oscillation has been extensively studied to explore possible drag control methods, mechanisms and efficacy - particularly for incompressible flows. We performed direct numerical simulation for fully developed turbulent channel flow to establish how effective spanwise wall oscillation is when the flow is compressible and also to document its drag reduction (DR) trend with Mach number. Drag reduction DR is first investigated for three different bulk Mach numbers Mb D0:3, 0:8 and 1:5 at a fixed bulk Reynolds number Reb D3000. At a given velocity amplitude AC (D12), DR at MbD0:3 agrees with the strictly incompressible case; at MbD0:8, DR exhibits a similar trend to that at Mb D 0:3: DR increases with the oscillation period TC to a maximum and then decreases gradually. However, at Mb D 1:5, DR monotonically increases with TC. In addition, the maximum DR is found to increase with Mb. For Mb D 1:5, similar to the incompressible case, DR increases with AC, but the rate of increase decreases at larger AC. Unlike the flow behaviour when incompressible, the flow surprisingly relaminarizes when it is supersonic (at AC D 18 and TC D 300) - this enigmatic behaviour requires further detailed studies for different domain sizes, Reb and Mb. The Reynolds number effect on DR is also investigated. Although DR generally decreases with Reb, it is less affected at small TC, but drops rapidly at large TC. We introduce a simple scaling for the oscillation period as T∗ DTC C lC I =lC C , with lC I and lC C denoting the mean streak spacing for incompressible and compressible cases, respectively. At the same semi-local Reynolds number Re∗τ c = Reτ √pc=√w=.μc=μw/(subscripts c and w denote quantities at the channel centre and wall, respectively), DR as a function of T∗ exhibits good agreement between the supersonic and strictly incompressible cases, with the optimal oscillation period becoming Mb-invariant as T∗ opt ≈100.
KW - compressible boundary layers
KW - drag reduction
KW - turbulence control
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85073161058&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1017/jfm.2019.727
DO - 10.1017/jfm.2019.727
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:85073161058
SN - 0022-1120
VL - 880
SP - 388
EP - 429
JO - Journal of Fluid Mechanics
JF - Journal of Fluid Mechanics
ER -