TY - JOUR
T1 - Ultra-low temperature frosting in cryogenic engineering
T2 - Mechanisms, methods, features, and control strategies
AU - Naqvi, Syed Murawat Abbas
AU - Zhang, Xuan
AU - Song, Mengjie
AU - Zhang, Long
AU - Jing, Lei
AU - Shao, Keke
AU - Munir, Umair
AU - Rafique, Faisal
AU - Waqas, Muhammad
AU - Bahrami, Hamid Reza
AU - Hamid, Mohammad
AU - Saleem, Adeel
N1 - Publisher Copyright:
© 2026 Elsevier Ltd
PY - 2026/12
Y1 - 2026/12
N2 - Frosting below −100 °C represents a distinct cryogenic regime in which vapor deposition is governed mainly by desublimation, high supersaturation, and limited surface diffusion rather than conventional condensation–freezing. This review synthesizes recent advances in ultra-low temperature frosting, emphasizing the mechanisms, morphologies, modeling approaches, and frost-control challenges that distinguish cryogenic systems from ordinary refrigeration conditions. Reported studies show that desublimation-driven growth produces highly porous and irregular frost structures, including wisteria-like, shrub-shaped, and thread-like morphologies, which rapidly increase thermal resistance and degrade the performance of LNG vaporizers, aerospace precoolers, and related cryogenic equipment. Existing simulations confirm the dominant role of vapor-phase mass transfer and frost–fog coupling, but remain limited by simplified geometries, incomplete validation, and insufficient representation of frost deformation, detachment, and structural evolution. Surface-based anti-frosting strategies developed for moderate subzero conditions show reduced effectiveness in this regime, indicating the need for integrated diagnostic, modeling, and de-/anti-frosting frameworks specifically designed for cryogenic environments. This review identifies the critical knowledge gaps and provides a unified basis for future prediction and control of ultra-low temperature frosting.
AB - Frosting below −100 °C represents a distinct cryogenic regime in which vapor deposition is governed mainly by desublimation, high supersaturation, and limited surface diffusion rather than conventional condensation–freezing. This review synthesizes recent advances in ultra-low temperature frosting, emphasizing the mechanisms, morphologies, modeling approaches, and frost-control challenges that distinguish cryogenic systems from ordinary refrigeration conditions. Reported studies show that desublimation-driven growth produces highly porous and irregular frost structures, including wisteria-like, shrub-shaped, and thread-like morphologies, which rapidly increase thermal resistance and degrade the performance of LNG vaporizers, aerospace precoolers, and related cryogenic equipment. Existing simulations confirm the dominant role of vapor-phase mass transfer and frost–fog coupling, but remain limited by simplified geometries, incomplete validation, and insufficient representation of frost deformation, detachment, and structural evolution. Surface-based anti-frosting strategies developed for moderate subzero conditions show reduced effectiveness in this regime, indicating the need for integrated diagnostic, modeling, and de-/anti-frosting frameworks specifically designed for cryogenic environments. This review identifies the critical knowledge gaps and provides a unified basis for future prediction and control of ultra-low temperature frosting.
KW - Cryogenic systems
KW - De-/anti-frosting strategies
KW - Desublimation
KW - Frost morphology
KW - Ultra-low temperature frosting
UR - https://www.scopus.com/pages/publications/105045423770
U2 - 10.1016/j.rser.2026.117254
DO - 10.1016/j.rser.2026.117254
M3 - Review article
AN - SCOPUS:105045423770
SN - 1364-0321
VL - 242
JO - Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews
JF - Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews
M1 - 117254
ER -